Cold Case Jury | The Shark Arm Mystery | Jury's Verdict
Home This Case tri Read dot Evidence dot Jury's Verdict

The Jury's Verdict

CASE:The Shark Arm Mystery DATE:1935

Below is the overall verdict and jury poll of The Shark Arm Mystery readers.

As of 18:16 on 4 February 2023, the verdict of the Cold Case Jury is:


Brady was forced to cover up the murder

Jury Size: 112

The Jury Poll
Verdict Vote %
Accessory. Brady was forced to cover up the murder38
Conspirator. Brady and Reginald Holmes worked together to murder Smith34
Instigator. Brady arranged the murder in revenge for the shelving of Stanley Watson29

Further tables showing verdicts broken down by demographic data will be available in due course.

Total number of jurors: 112

Home Page